Science Class Question?

Question:When I was in school our teacher told us that no matter what one of us suggested it could be classified as a solid, liquid, or gas. She went around the room asking for suggestions and I said "What about time?" The room went silent. Then someone else said that a clock is a solid so time had to be a solid. The teacher agreed and went to the next student. Thirty some years later I still disagree but have never had a good answer. Anyone here care to take a stab at it?

Answers:
I wish you had been a student of mine. Those are the very ideas I try to get my students to think of. I challenge my students to think of something that isn't matter. We finally get around to naming things such as energy, ideas, feelings, spirits. Our test is whether something can occupy the same space at the same time if it can then one of them can't be matter. We use the light in the room as our example. The air is not pushed out of the room simply because you turn the lights on. I ask if a burning light bulb weighs more than a darkened light bulb. Matter has mass so the addition of the light must not be matter. Unfortunately your teacher did what many teachers do when they don't know how to respond. Sorry.
Materials exist as solids, liquids and gases, and as a mixture of these states. They may be natural or man made and they have different textures and properties.

I see time as an idea, rather than a material, and as the teacher that is how I would have explained it. Things made of matter can be qualified as solids, liquids, or gases, but not everything we can mention can be classified as a solid, liquid, or gas, so if that is what she said, she was in error. What about peace, loneliness, fear, etc.? Some things are ideas, or feelings, or philosophies.

I hope this helps.
Time is not a physical object. time is a noun though. remember that a noun is any concrete person, place, thing, or abstract idea? time is an abstract object because it isn't tangible. since time isn't concrete it cannot be classified as having matter. so time cannot be a solid, liquid, gas, or plasma.
Time is like a teacher. It teaches us to do things constructively becuase it not infinite to us.
I too had teachers who told me odd things, and to this day I dont know where he was coming from. My HS bio teacher told us that humans were the third most intelligent species. dolphins second and memes first. BAH messed me up for a long time. people thought i was nuts asking what a meme is.

Anyways as far as states of matter goes there are now two more to add. plasma and perhaps even the bose-einstein condensate.

Time was an excellent answer, and your teacher should have recognized it. abstract concept, not a function of matter. In fact it might not even exist... fundamental part of the universe, or human conciousness construct?

Heres some other things that do not exist as solid liquid or gasses

lightning
solar wind
light
magnetism
electrons
gravity

good luck

This article contents is post by this website user, EduQnA.com doesn't promise its accuracy.



More Questions & Answers...
  • I want to work as a KG teacher in Conneticut. What are the certificates I need to have?
  • How to get payed the most being a teacher?
  • What will encourage someone to consider a teaching career?
  • Differents between language and dialougs?
  • Who is a large, good, fair, publishing house in the USA? Someone who has experienced publishing please, HELP.?
  • What is and where may one find the proper requirements to be a substitute teacher?
  • What are some good movies about teaching?
  • The best way to make money online..? for someone whose smart, fluent in english and creative?
  • Copyright 2006-2007 EduQnA.com All Rights Reserved.